Guest Blog: Absence of Leadership a Sad Indictment on the Communications Industry

July 1st, 2009 by Niall McKeown
Guest Blogger: Gareth Dunlop, MD of Tibus

Guest Blogger: Gareth Dunlop, MD of Tibus

Imagine you are a small business owner with 10 to 50 employees.  Your business has been growing well for nearly ten years now and is really starting to perform for you.  You were just planning a new phase of growth in the early part of 2008 when deep recession hit.  Your margins are squeezed, your people are stressed, and not only are there no bonuses this year, there are no pay-rises for any of your staff.  You are concerned that you will need to lay people off.

You check the local business press for inspiration and guidance.

What do you read?

“Keep your foot on the advertising pedal”
“Marketing through a recession”
“Investing in building your brand”

The titles have been altered to ensure that this doesn’t become personal, but the message in each is the same – that businesses should maintain or increase their marketing spend in a recession.

Really?

So given the choice of laying someone off, or reducing marketing, you should lay someone off?
Or given the choice of a direct foreign territories sales visit to close a hot lead, or continuing to market, you should market?
Or given the choice of finalising a product innovation, or continuing marketing investment, you should continue marketing?

The communications industry needs to wise up and grow up.  I have yet to read a single article by an author making these recommendations who has put a penny of their own money into implementing these recommendations for their own business.

Clearly there are many businesses who should definitely reduce communications spend.  And more importantly, there are yet more businesses who radically need to alter how their communications budget is spent, by realising that the day of the interruption marketer is gone forever, and has been replaced by the age of the permission based marketer.

And that permission based marketing happens online, in a measurable and accountable manner.

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Marketing Water and IT Oil

June 30th, 2009 by Niall McKeown

oil-and-waterFiona, the Marketing Manager of a major hotel group often phones the IT department to complain when her mouse is faulty, her PC is running slow or the printer runs out of toner.  At the same time the IT department are bedding down extremely complex routing traffic shaping protocols to ensure that voice data gets higher priority over email across their wide area network and that the company infrastructure is free from Trojans, a threat that could collapse the entire group infrastructure within moments.

Fiona has no idea of the level of complexity and commitment the IT team has to put into keeping the business running.  She never calls to congratulate them on keeping the key company infrastructure running for 365 days without fail.  The IT team is as important to a business as oil is to an engine.

Stuart works in the IT department.  Often distracted by being called away from his complex world to perform tasks for the Marketing department.  He views their efforts as little more than spending big budgets on pretty pictures. “Anyone could do that job!” claims Stuart.

Stuart doesn’t see the effort that goes into creating the stories around the pictures, the long hours spent on exhibition stands, the detailed review of website content and customer journey planning needed to turn a prospect into a customer.  Marketing is the water needed to make the business live, grow and prosper.

Internet Marketing requires both oil and water.  It’s an odd combination, as they don’t readily mix. Often we make the mistake of outsourcing Online Marketing decisions to IT experts and frequently make the mistake of having traditional Marketing experts telling us what is technically achievable.  To create a successful online marketing strategy, add three-quarters water to one-quarter oil.

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Putting Your Pricing Online

June 24th, 2009 by Niall McKeown

At a recent online marketing conference for the Wedding industry, Mary from Wicklow asks “I make specialist wedding stationary – should I put my pricing online?”  The four guest speakers were split.  My opinion was that you should display pricing guides if possible.

My reasons for arguing that pricing guides should be put online is because in a price sensitive market – such as wedding stationary, it is one of the first queries any perspective customer has.  If you had a bricks and mortar shop, and the potential customer walked through your door there is a good chance you can change the terms of engagement by asking the question “well what budget do you have in mind?”  Online the same privilege does not exist.  Customer expectations are dashed if they want price guidance and you don’t give it to them. Your competitor is only two clicks away and your competitor may address the price concern head-on.

There are certain industries that are neither price driven or suitable for generic pricing.  Those industries are sensitive to other aspects influencing the customers’ choice.  Unfortunately in most industries price is a primary factor when making choice.  Unless your product or service is the clear market leader, withholding pricing may mean you’re not even considered as your compeitor overcomes customer questions and builds trust.

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Pay-Per-Goal Search Engine Optimisation

June 22nd, 2009 by Niall McKeown

The big problem with Search Engine Optimisation is that there can be no guarantees accompanying your investment.  Being in the top 5 search results for your key terms is difficult to achieve and with a swift change of the Google algorithms can render your investment void.

The website owner understands the need for SEO, but fears the risk of low return on investment.  Removing that risk and allowing the site owner and the SEO expert to share rewards in the lift of business achieved from improved search results, is the likely future for SEO.

If the site owner’s goal is to get more people to attend an event, donate money, purchase a product or generate sales calls, it is now really easy to measure where the sites traffic comes from and calculate the lift in business coming from search.

Using the model of Pay Per Goal SEO the site owner needs to be generous in the reward on offer, as the SEO expert has taken 100% of the risk.  The SEO expert needs to have the confidence they can affect change quickly.

seo2

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Should a blog be part of your online marketing mix?

June 17th, 2009 by Niall McKeown

YES: If you can passionately articulate something that both you and your customers care about.  If your passion is about politics, sailing boats or saving small puppies and it corresponds with your line of business, then blogging and engaging with those like minded will enhance the likelihood of you being talked about, your influence becoming policy or donations coming in to help save more puppies.

NO: If the only thing you can blog about is what you had for breakfast or the new wallpaper in your office.  Because you want to talk doesn’t mean others want to listen.  In my experience blogging is often added to an online marketing strategy for the wrong reasons, such as to try and enhance search engine position or to fulfill the desires of the CEO.  Unless the blog integrates with the other elements of your digital marketing strategy, feeds your email marketing, your tweets and enhances the readers understanding of your topic of expertise, then it is likely  your blog will have no following.

blogging2

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Creating an Online Social Media Engagement Strategy.

June 16th, 2009 by Niall McKeown
Erinn McKeown not barbershop kid :-)

Erinn McKeown not barbershop kid :-)

A young boy enters a barbershop and the barber whispers to his customer, “This is the dumbest kid in the world. Watch while I prove it to you.”

The barber puts £5 note in one hand and a £1 coin in the other, then calls the boy over and asks, “Which do you want, son?” The boy takes the £1 coin and leaves. “What did I tell you?” said the barber. “That kid never learns!”

Later, when the customer leaves, he sees the same young boy coming out of the ice cream shop. “Hey, son! May I ask you a question? Why did you take the £1 instead of the fiver?” The boy licked his cone and replied, “Because the day I take the fiver, the game is over!”

If we use social media to shout our advertising message it is the same as accepting the £5 note.  We may see a short gain but we loose the prospect of ever tasting the ice cream in the future.  Creating the right online social media strategy is a hot topic for many orginisations right now.  Follow the young kids plan by playing the long game, refrain from taking the obvious route.

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Marketing stories spread faster than marketing facts.

June 13th, 2009 by Niall McKeown
The Merchant

The Merchant

I have the great privilege to work with one of the worlds leading boutique hotels; The Merchant Hotel in Belfast.  When creating their new online marketing strategy we discussed the power of using stories to help in stimulating interest and how a story spreads much better than a low room rate or an interesting menu.

When the highly ornate and modernised Victorian building opened, it could have been marketed for its high impact visual features and quirky historic artifices but that wasn’t how the marketing/conversations started.  It started around it serving the worlds most expensive cocktail.

This is marketing genius at work.  The story of opulence or history is harder to pass on and not quite as interesting.  The worlds most expensive cocktail however lets us know exactly what sort of hotel you’re talking about and of course, we’re likely to tell someone else about it.

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Could Online PR save the Newspaper?

June 6th, 2009 by Niall McKeown

newspaperThe traditional daily newspaper is in trouble.  Advertising revenues are in steep decline along with copy sales as the internet causes major disruption to print, one of the oldest forms of existing mass media.  If however we as marketers grasped the value of online peer review coverage, would we pay for the privilege of outbound links from newspaper websites in our published PR articles?

A regional newspaper may for example have an ABC audited readership of around 70,000.  On the other hand, the online version of the publication has around 1 million unique viewers each month.  Tradition would have it that if you make the print version, you are pretty sure to make the online version for stories of reasonable resonance with the reader.  This may not feel like you got double the bang for your buck, but consider a scenario whereby you got your embedded video along with an outbound link to a landing page dedicated to the article published in the online version of the newspaper.  This is a small example of Online PR and the implications are massive.

Firstly having peer review publications linking to your website will help your Search Engine Optimisation (SEO).  Next, your article will be stored and indexed by Google, Bing and Yahoo! meaning your PR article has perpetual use and relevance and can be found in the future.  Third your PR is seen by people overseas and outside the normal distribution demographic of the print publication giving your extend reach.  Finally you can track with total accuracy the number of inquiries created, videos watched and links clicked without the aid of third party services.  In other words, you can see if you get Return On Investment (ROI)  for your marketing spend.

With all this in mind, would you still prefer column inches to page impressions? Would you pay to have the privilege of having your video embedded in the article and would you pay to have an outbound link to your website from the newspaper website?  So if the economic model of online display ads is not working for newspapers, could charging for enhanced online PR fill the gap?

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Is website design overrated?

June 1st, 2009 by Niall McKeown

In my experience, few customers visit a website because of its design. There are few companies, organisations or political movements that win or influence their intended target market by having the prettiest website, yet this is usually the greatest bone of contention between Marketing Managers and the web design company.

Unless you sell web design services or design is pivotal to your business, like a boutique hotel, then content and structure are more important than design.

Amazon will never win a Best Website Design Award. What it will win is best and most appropriate content awards, as well as having a killer customer journey.  So the next time you need a new website, perhaps prioritise your time and efforts into creating a:

  • Clear online strategy with defined outcomes and objectives
  • Customer focused structure with clear customer journey and easy to find call-to-action triggers - such as call us on this number or add to basket or donate now
  • Concise and appropriate content.  Use video where it works better than text and animation when explaining complex interactions
  • Good website design

It is simple to criticise website design because design is subjective.  I argue that you should spend more time debating what really matters - the objectives of the site, its structure, the customer journey and ultimately the content.

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Grasping the value of permission marketing

May 25th, 2009 by Niall McKeown

This is not an impossible scenario to imagine.  You place an ad in a specialist magazine read by a supposed 10,000 enthusiasts that could do with your product or service.  The ad cost you £500 + £200 in design, totaling £700.

Out of the 10,000 readers, it is a proven statistic that if you are really lucky and your ad really connects with the reader then 7% of the readers will remember your ad.  That means 700 have acknowledged the ad.  Out of those 700, 5% may follow the call to action and call you.  That is 35 possible enquires.  Remember this is just 35 phone calls; the customer still has yet to buy your product or service.

So what have you bought here?  You have bought the attention of 35 people for £700.  That’s £20 per person attention.  So the question then turns, how much would you pay to gain the permission of a potentially interested customer, get their email address and market to them multiple times? 

The moral of this tale is that having permission to market to a customer and having their email address or following on twitter/Facebook/Bebo is of massive value and a privilege worth many thousands of marketing pounds.

  • Share/Save/Bookmark